Temporary and Permanent Restraining Orders in CA: What’s the Difference?

What Is a Restraining Order?

A restraining order is a legal order issued by a court. It prohibits one person from contacting or coming near another person.

Victims often seek these orders to ensure their safety. Courts issue restraining orders in various situations, including cases of domestic violence, stalking, or harassment. The primary purpose of restraining orders is to stop harmful behaviors and provide a sense of security to victims.

Temporary Restraining Orders (TROs)

A Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) offers immediate protection. Courts often grant these orders quickly, usually without the restrained party present. The petitioner's case often requires urgency, so judges issue TROs to prevent imminent harm or threats. A TRO remains in effect until the court holds a hearing where both parties can present their arguments.

To obtain a TRO, the petitioner must fill out specific forms. These forms typically include a request for a TRO and supporting documents outlining the reasons for the request. Applicants should detail incidents of abuse or threats. In some cases, individuals may need to provide evidence, such as photographs or witness statements.

Emergencies often necessitate a TRO. For example, a victim of domestic violence may seek a TRO after an assault or credible threats from a partner. These orders provide immediate relief and establish temporary boundaries until a more permanent solution is arranged.

TROs have a limited duration. They usually last for 20 to 25 days, leading up to the court hearing for a permanent restraining order. During this time, law enforcement can enforce the order. If the restrained party violates the TRO, law enforcement can arrest them, which adds a layer of security for the protected individual.

Typical situations warranting a TRO include:

  • Stalking
  • Harassment
  • Domestic violence
  • Threats of violence

These situations require immediate intervention from the legal system to protect victims.

Permanent Restraining Orders

A Permanent Restraining Order serves a more long-term purpose. Courts issue these orders after a thorough hearing process. The hearing allows both parties to present their case. Petitioners must provide evidence to demonstrate the need for long-term protection. Such evidence may include testimony, documentation, witnesses, police reports, medical records, and emails or messages from the restrained individual. During the hearing, the restrained party also has the opportunity to defend themselves.

Permanent restraining orders remain in effect for several years or until the court modifies or terminates them. Courts enforce these orders vigorously. Violations of permanent restraining orders can result in criminal charges, including felony charges, depending on the circumstances.

Circumstances leading to a permanent restraining order include

  • Ongoing threats
  • Persistent stalking
  • Repeated harassment
  • A pattern of abusive behavior

Such orders ensure victims obtain long-term protection and peace of mind.

Key Differences Between TROs and Permanent Restraining Orders

The primary distinction between TROs and permanent restraining is their duration. TROs provide temporary relief, lasting a few weeks, while permanent orders offer lasting protection.

The processes for obtaining each type also differ significantly. Courts issue TROs swiftly to address immediate concerns. Obtaining a permanent order requires an extensive court hearing and a greater burden of proof. The timeline for each process can vary widely, with TROs often granted on the same day of the application, but permanent orders require scheduling and preparation time.

Levels of proof vary for each type of order. A TRO requires an immediate showing of need, where the petitioner often provides sworn statements or evidence indicating a credible threat. In contrast, petitioners must present compelling evidence in court to obtain a permanent restraining order, demonstrating ongoing risk or harm.

The implications for both parties may also differ. A TRO may feel abrupt and imposing on the restrained party, who might be unaware of the legal proceedings. Conversely, a permanent restraining order involves a full hearing, which may give both parties an opportunity to present their case more comprehensively.

When to Seek Legal Guidance

Navigating the complexities of restraining orders can be overwhelming. Individuals should seek legal guidance to understand their rights fully and the processes involved. Legal advice helps individuals make informed decisions based on their circumstances.

If you need protection, Burch Shepard Family Law Group is here for you. We can help with both permanent and temporary orders, so contact us online or call our team directly at (949) 565-4158.

Categories